The Checkered Political Landscape
Sometimes Canadian politics feel less like a sophisticated game of chess and more like a round of checkers played at a backyard family gathering. Maxime Bernier, leader of the People's Party of Canada (PPC), finds himself in the delicate situation of a checkers player on the losing side of a game against a particularly crafty grandparent. His aim is to hop over 20% of the votes in the upcoming Portage-Lisgar by-election. Hitting this percentage would mean he's not knocked out just yet, and his checker piece remains on the board.
In another corner of the garden, Pierre Poilievre, leader of the Conservative Party, is trying to corner the right-wing vote market like it's a forgotten piece on the back row of the checkerboard. His challenge? Outjump Bernier without sending his own checker pieces skidding off the table.
Surprising Moves and Political Strategy
Interestingly, the Conservative Party has recently ousted a nomination contestant who was outspokenly pro-life, prompting many to speculate that this was the deciding factor in their decision. This move can be likened to a surprising jump in a game of checkers where a piece is unexpectedly removed from the board.
Bernier, in contrast, seems ready to use the Conservative Party's checker piece removal to his advantage, making a tit-for-tat move by pledging to introduce an abortion law, a move that shouts out to social conservative voters feeling sidelined by the recent actions of the Conservative Party. The goal? Paint his party as the go-to refuge for right-leaning voters, offering a brand of conservatism that is unafraid to address their concerns.
In a return move, Poilievre’s local candidate has responded to Bernier's abortion ban proposition with a vow to halt the "Liberal culture of death." Cleverly, he deflects from the abortion issue and concentrates on assisted suicide, a nuanced move that could resonate with social conservatives without inciting the same divisive reaction often linked to abortion.
Meanwhile, Poilievre is trying to navigate this without stepping on any political rakes. He needs to craft a response that maintains his party's unity, appeals to a broad audience, and sidelines the PPC, without alienating key conservative players.
The Influence of Pro-Life Organizations and the Significance of the Portage-Lisgar By-Election
As this high-stakes situation continues, the impact of significant pro-life organizations such as RightNow and Campaign Life Coalition is crucial. If they decide to fully shift their support from the Conservative Party to the People's Party, we could see a substantial reconfiguration of the political landscape.
The Portage-Lisgar by-election not only serves as the stage for Bernier’s and Poilievre's political contest, but it also stands as a key indicator of the strength of socially conservative sentiments within the electorate. If Bernier secures over 20% of the vote, it could signal a shift in voter sentiment away from the moderate centre, which could dramatically reshape the contours of Canadian politics.
Moreover, the upcoming by-election becomes more than a contest for a single seat. It serves as a testing ground for the strength of the socially conservative base, assessing whether there's a sizable group feeling sidelined by the current political offerings. It is clear that the dynamics in play are far from ordinary by-elections.
Poilievre's Shift Towards Pro-Choice
Simultaneously, Poilievre has shown a fascinating shift in his political strategy. Once regarded as a pro-life advocate by the influential Campaign Life Coalition, he is now widely seen as solidly pro-choice. Furthermore, his tactful adaptability in the face of evolving events, such as last year's Freedom Convoy, is noteworthy. For a whole year, Poilievre remained silent on vaccine discussions in the context of Covid until the truckers brought the issue to his doorstep in Ottawa.
Anticipating the Performance of the People's Party
The Conservatives are still deeply entrenched in the political fabric of Portage Lisgar. They're highly likely to secure this seat, but the true anticipation lies in how the People's Party will perform. A result over the 20% line for the People's Party would be a crowning move, demonstrating the party's resilience.
The Cautionary Tale of Andrew Scheer
As we continue to observe this fascinating drama of Canadian politics, it would be wise to reflect on the cautionary tale of former Conservative leader Andrew Scheer. His management of pro-life stances, which initially catapulted him to the leadership of his party, left both ends of the spectrum feeling as if they were collateral damage in a poorly executed political maneuver.
Notably, despite his political missteps, Scheer has emerged as Poilievre’s most trusted advisor and right hand man. This unexpected alliance injects a further degree of complexity into this whole situation.
Scheer's prolonged silence on his pro-life position and his subsequent inability to articulate a clear stance left many of his social conservative supporters feeling sidelined. His delayed assertion that he remained pro-life did little to quell the discontent among his supporters, as trust had already been dented and his competence called into question.
Similarly, Scheer's missteps had far-reaching consequences for his party in the general election. A much-anticipated "blue wave" in Quebec, which data suggested the Conservatives were well-positioned to harness for a substantial number of parliamentary seats, instead became a beachhead for the Bloc Quebecois. The blow was considerable; the potential Conservative seats evaporated due to Scheer's mismanagement of the abortion issue. Quebec voters were alarmed by the perception that he would impose a pro-life agenda, while social conservatives felt neglected by his perceived lack of commitment to their cause.
Pro-Life Conservative MPs: Aligning with U.S-Based Organizations
Drawing on the experiences of Andrew Scheer, some pro-life Conservative MPs seem to be making their own checker-like leaps, aligning with U.S.-based pro-life organizations such as the Susan B. Anthony Foundation, where they have traveled to meet with and learn from, searching for issues that might resonate with social conservatives. How Poilievre reacts to this could significantly affect his party's future.
From Checkers to Chess: The Power of the Voters
While we witness the unfolding spectacle of Canadian politics, we must remember that every move has wider implications. The question posed by the Portage-Lisgar by-election is whether voters want politics to continue as a straightforward game of checkers, or if they are ready for it to evolve into a strategic game of chess.
One Last Thing: Stay Connected
Before you leave, I'd like to extend an invitation to you. If you've enjoyed this analysis, or if you simply appreciate a unique perspective on Canadian politics laden with vivid metaphors, I'd be thrilled if you'd subscribe to my substack - it’s free!
As a seasoned Conservative strategist operating at all levels of government, I offer a unique viewpoint that you might not find elsewhere. Regardless of your own political affiliation, I believe my insights could provide a fresh perspective, adding depth to your understanding of the political landscape.
I don't shy away from using metaphors to illustrate my points – they're part of my style, and I make no apologies for it!
If you subscribe, you won't miss any future writings. And if you know someone else who might appreciate this kind of content, please feel free to share it with them. My hope is to foster rich conversations around Canadian politics, and your support in spreading the word is deeply appreciated.
So, come join me on this fascinating journey as we navigate the intricate checkerboard of Canadian politics together. I look forward to your company.
The Poilievre-Bernier Checkered Duel: Navigating Abortion Politics
Conservatives allow abortion to become an issue every election and that only benefits the Liberals and NDP. I suggest the CPC invite the anti-abortion crowd, aka "pro-life", to join another Party, such as the Christian Heritage Party, whose main platform is anti-abortion. It's time to stop the tail wagging the dog, which seems to be a feature of Canadian politics.